AI Moderator or Human Moderator: When to Use Each
An AI moderator is good at many comparable interviews on a stable guide. A person is better for new questions, high stakes and tasks where the moderator must react to what it sees.
Overview
An AI moderator asks the same guide in every session. It works at any hour, in many sessions at once, and needs no booking. A person adapts to the room, builds a relationship and notices things that are not said.
The choice is not about which is better in general. It is about what this study needs. Many teams use both. A person does the first few conversations. Then an AI moderator asks the refined guide to more people.
User Evaluation has an AI interview study type and a human interview study type. In an AI interview you can listen in to the live transcript. On the Team and Scale plans you can also steer the moderator while it runs.
Rules
- 01
Use an AI moderator when the guide is stable and you need comparable answers.
The AI moderator asks the same questions with the same probe logic in every session. This makes it easier to compare groups, such as new and long-term customers.
- 02
Use an AI moderator when participants are hard to schedule.
Participants start the interview when they want. This helps with busy professionals, shift workers and people in many time zones.
- 03
Use a person when you do not know the right questions yet.
Early discovery changes direction after every conversation. A person can follow a new topic for ten minutes. Run the first few interviews yourself, then write the AI guide from what you learned.
Do notLaunch 30 AI interviews on a new market with a guide written from assumptions.
DoDo four calls yourself. Rewrite the guide from the transcripts. Then launch the AI study.
- 04
Use a person when the moderator must react to what the participant does on screen.
In User Evaluation the AI moderator only hears the participant. It does not see the camera or the shared screen. It asks people to say what they see and do. For tasks where you must react to a click, a person gives better control.
- 05
Use a person for conversations that are also relationship work.
A key account, a buyer in an open deal or a senior executive may expect a person. The interview is also a signal of how much you value them.
- 06
Consider an AI moderator when participants may hold back criticism from your team.
Some participants find it easier to criticize a product when no person from the company listens. Do not assume this for every audience. Read the first transcripts to see if answers are candid.
- 07
Use a person, or a carefully limited AI guide, for topics that can cause distress.
A person can notice distress in a voice and decide to stop. An AI moderator follows its instructions. If you use AI, write explicit stop and no-probe rules.
- 08
Listen in to the first AI sessions.
The first sessions show if the guide works with real people. You can pause the study and fix the guide before most sessions run.
Checklist before launch
- You can write every question as the exact words to say.
- The study does not need the moderator to react to what is on the screen.
- No participant expects a person because of an existing relationship.
- Sensitive questions have stop rules and no-probe notes.
- You plan to listen in to the first sessions.
- You know what you will compare across sessions.
Questions
For a stable guide with clear probe notes, an AI moderator gives consistent and usable interviews. For early exploration and high-stakes conversations, a skilled person is usually better.
Yes. Run the first interviews yourself and refine the guide. Then let the AI moderator ask it to more people.
A person can react to what they see and change the topic during the call. A person can also judge the emotional state of the participant.
In User Evaluation you can listen in to the live transcript. On Team and Scale plans you can steer it. Send a line to ask, push deeper, skip a question or wrap up.
Ask real people your question
The AI moderator interviews screened people by voice or text. Each claim in the study report links to its clip. The first 3 interviews are free.