Use it for
- Transcripts of switch interviews with people who bought, started or switched to a product in the last 90 days.
- A short timeline for each participant: the date of the first thought, the purchase and the first use.
- The product or category that the people switched to and the one they switched from.
Steps
- Build a timeline for each participant
Before you code forces, mark the timeline in each transcript. Find the first thought, the passive looking, the active looking, the decision and the first use. Some participants skip a stage. Record that too.
- Code each passage with one force
Read each passage about the switch and ask one question: does it move the person toward the new solution or hold them back? Then choose Push, Pull, Anxiety or Habit. A passage gets one force code only.
- Add the timeline stage
Give each force passage a second code: the timeline stage in which it happened. A Push in the first thought stage tells a different story from a Push in the active looking stage.
- Draw a forces diagram per participant
For each participant, list the forces on four sides of one page. Push and Pull go on the side of the switch. Anxiety and Habit go on the other side. Compare the sides to see what made the switch happen.
- Group participants by their strongest forces
Put participants with the same main Push and the same main Anxiety together. Each group often has a different job. Name each group by the progress it wants, not by its demographics.
- Write the job statements
For each group, write one job statement: when [situation], I want to [motivation], so I can [outcome]. Use only words from the passages.
Codebook
Copy the codebook as a table. It pastes into a spreadsheet with one row for each code.
Push of the situation
A problem with the old way that makes the person want to change.
- Include
- The participant describes frustration, failure or a new demand that the old product or method cannot meet.
- Exclude
- The participant describes what attracts them to the new product. Use Pull for that. A Push is about the old way, a Pull is about the new one.
- Example
- “The old app lost my notes twice in one week. After the second time I knew I had to move.”
Pull of the new solution
An attraction to the new product or method that makes the person want to switch to it.
- Include
- The participant describes a better life with the new product, or a feature or story that drew them in.
- Exclude
- The participant only describes what was wrong with the old way, with no mention of the new one. Use Push for that.
- Example
- “My friend showed me her weekly plan on her phone and I thought, I want my week to look like that.”
Anxiety of the new solution
A worry about the new product or method that holds the person back from the switch.
- Include
- The participant doubts the new product: whether it works, its cost, the learning time or what others will think.
- Exclude
- The participant describes comfort with or attachment to the old way. Use Habit for that. Anxiety looks forward at the new, Habit looks back at the old.
- Example
- “I kept wondering if my clients would be able to open the files, or if I would look unprofessional.”
Habit of the present
An attachment to the old way that holds the person back, even when the old way has problems.
- Include
- The participant describes routines, sunk effort, familiarity or the ease of not changing.
- Exclude
- The participant describes a problem with the old way. Use Push for that, even if they stayed with it.
- Example
- “I had used the same spreadsheet for six years. I knew every shortcut, and that was hard to give up.”
First thought
The moment when the person first thought that the old way was not good enough.
- Include
- The participant describes the earliest point in time when change came to mind, even if they did nothing about it.
- Exclude
- The participant had already started to look at options. Use Passive looking or Active looking for that.
- Example
- “The first time I thought about it was when my daughter was born and I had no time for the old routine.”
Passive looking
A period when the person noticed options but did not spend time or money to search.
- Include
- The participant noticed ads, heard friends talk or read about options without a plan to act.
- Exclude
- The participant set time aside to compare options, ask for demos or try products. Use Active looking for that.
- Example
- “For a few months I would see ads for meal kits and think, maybe one day.”
Active looking
A period when the person put time or effort into finding and comparing options.
- Include
- The participant searched, compared, asked people for advice, read reviews or started trials.
- Exclude
- The participant describes the final moment of choice. Use Deciding for that.
- Example
- “I made a list of four apps and tried each one for a weekend.”
Deciding
The event that made the person commit to the switch at a specific time.
- Include
- The participant names what happened just before they paid or signed, such as a deadline or a final failure.
- Exclude
- The passage is about the reason for change in general with no specific moment. Code the force instead.
- Example
- “The trial ended on a Friday and I had a client call on Monday, so I just paid.”
First use
The experience of the first days with the new product, after the purchase.
- Include
- The participant describes setup, the first result, surprises, or the first moment they felt the switch was right or wrong.
- Exclude
- The passage is about the trial before the purchase. Use Active looking for that.
- Example
- “The first week I still opened the old app out of habit, then I deleted it from my home screen.”
Report outline
- The jobs: one job statement per group of participants, with the number of participants in each group.
- Forces diagram for each job: the main Push, Pull, Anxiety and Habit, each with one quote.
- The switch timeline: how long each stage took and which events moved people to the next stage.
- Anxieties that slow the switch, and what could reduce each one.
- Implications for product, marketing and sales, one line per job.
- Method: who was interviewed, when they switched, and limits of the sample.
Mistakes to avoid
- Do not give a passage two force codes. If you cannot choose, the passage has two ideas. Split it.
- Do not mix Anxiety and Habit. Anxiety is fear of the new product. Habit is comfort with the old one. They need different fixes.
- Do not interview people who switched more than 90 days ago. The timeline events fade, and people tell a cleaner story than what happened.
- Do not write jobs as features or demographics. "Busy parents" is not a job. "Plan meals in less time on Sunday" is closer.
Guides that use it