Concept Test Interview: Guide and Questions for a New Product Idea
Use this guide when you have a product idea on a page, an image or a short video. It checks if people understand the idea, if it fits their week and what stops them from trying it.
- Length
- 30 min
- Questions
- 13
- People
- 10 to 15 for each concept
- Sections
- 5
What this guide finds out
- If people understand the concept without help, in their own words.
- How the concept compares with what people use today.
- When and how often people would use it in a normal week.
- What worries people about the concept, and what proof they need before they try it.
When to use it
- You have two or three product ideas and want to choose one before you build.
- You have a landing page or mockup and want to know if the idea is clear.
- You discovered a problem and want to test one solution for it.
Who to talk to
People who have the problem that the concept solves and who decide what tools they use for it. Talk to 10 to 15 for each concept people. Each interview takes about 30 minutes.
The discussion guide
Each question has a probe note. The note tells the moderator, a person or an AI, what to do with the answer.
Before the concept
6 minLearn the current way before the concept changes the conversation.
Tell me how you deal with this problem today.
ProbeAsk for the last time it happened. Ask which tools or people were part of it.
What is the most annoying part of the way you do it now?
ProbeRecord the words they use. Later, compare these words with the words of the concept.
First reaction
6 minCapture the first reaction before any explanation.
Please look at this idea. Tell me what you see and what you think while you read it.
ProbeShow the concept at this question. Let them talk. Do not explain anything. Note the first words they say.
In your own words, what is this, and who is it for?
ProbeIf the answer is wrong, record the misunderstanding. Do not correct it until after the next question.
What would you use it for first?
ProbeAsk for a specific task from their week. A vague answer is a sign that the value is not clear.
Understanding
5 minFind what is unclear and what the concept must explain better.
Which part of the idea is unclear or confusing?
ProbeAsk what they think that part means. Then explain it in one sentence and ask if it changes their opinion.
How is this different from what you use today?
ProbeIf they say it is not different, ask what it would need to do to be worth a change.
Fit and value
8 minLearn if the concept fits into real life and what it is worth.
How would this fit into your week? When would you use it?
ProbeAsk for the day and the situation. Ask what they would stop doing to make time for it.
What would you expect to pay for this?
ProbeDo not suggest a number. Ask what they compare it with.
On a scale from 1 to 5, how likely are you to try this if it were available next month?
ProbeShow the scale on screen. Ask the reason for the score. Ask what would move it up by one point.
Concerns and close
5 minFind the barriers to a first try.
What worries you about this idea?
ProbeAsk about trust, effort to change and cost. Do not answer the worry. Record it.
What would you need to see before you try it?
ProbeAsk for the kind of proof: a free trial, a review, a demo or a friend who uses it.
Which part of the idea would you remove?
ProbeAsk why. Thank them and end the interview.
Example finding
Freelancers thought the concept was for large teams and said it was not for them, which was not the intent.
“It looks like something for a company with a project manager. I just need to send three invoices a month.”
Mistakes to avoid
- Do not explain the concept before the first reaction. The first reaction is the reaction of a real customer who reads your page alone.
- Do not take a high score as a promise to buy. Look at the worries and the proof people need.
- Do not show more than one concept to a person without a change in order. The first concept colors the others.
- Do not ask people who do not have the problem. Their opinion of the idea does not predict use.
Analyze the answers
Analysis templateThematic Analysis Codebook: Starter Codes for InterviewsUse this codebook as the first pass on interview transcripts about a task or a workflow. The 10 codes describe what people do and why, so themes come from behavior, not from opinions.Questions
A concept test interview shows a product idea to possible customers and asks what they understand and think. It tests the idea before the team builds it.
A short page, an image, a mockup or a short video is enough. Show what the product does and for whom, as a real customer would see it first.
Yes. In User Evaluation, you can show an image, a video, a website or a Figma prototype at a chosen question. You can also shuffle the order when you test more than one concept.
Plan 10 to 15 for each concept. If you compare concepts, give each person one concept, or change the order for each person.
Let the AI moderator ask these questions
The AI moderator interviews screened people by voice or text. Each claim in the study report links to its clip. The first 3 interviews are free.