Product-Market Fit Interview: Guide and Questions for Active Users
Use this guide with active users to check product-market fit. It asks how people would feel if they lost the product. Then it finds the main benefit, the alternative and the users who get the most value.
- Length
- 25 min
- Questions
- 13
- People
- 15 to 25
- Sections
- 5
What this guide finds out
- How many active users would be strongly disappointed to lose the product, and why.
- The main benefit, in the words of the users who value the product most.
- What users would use instead, and how hard that switch would be.
- Which type of user gets the most value, so that you can find more of them.
When to use it
- You have a few hundred active users and want to know if you have product-market fit.
- Growth is slow and you are not sure which segment to focus on.
- You want a baseline before a large change to the product.
Who to talk to
Users who used the product at least twice in the last two weeks. Talk to 15 to 25 people. Each interview takes about 25 minutes.
The discussion guide
Each question has a probe note. The note tells the moderator, a person or an AI, what to do with the answer.
Use
4 minLearn how the product fits into the work or life of the user.
What do you use the product for, and how did it become part of your routine?
ProbeAsk when they started and what made them keep using it after the first week.
When did you last use it, and what did you do?
ProbeAsk for the specific task. This checks that the person is an active user.
The disappointment test
6 minMeasure how much the user depends on the product.
How would you feel if you could no longer use this product?
ProbeShow an on-screen choice with three answers: disappointed a great deal, a little disappointed, not disappointed. Then ask for the reason.
What would you miss most?
ProbeAsk for one thing. If they name a feature, ask what it lets them do.
If the product disappeared, who on your team or in your family would notice first?
ProbeThis shows if the value is shared or personal. If nobody else would notice, record that.
Benefit and audience
6 minFind the main benefit and the type of user who gets the most from it.
What is the main benefit you get from the product?
ProbeAsk for an example from the last month. Listen for an outcome, such as time saved or a better result.
What type of person do you think would get the most from this product?
ProbeAsk them to describe that person: role, situation and problem. Users often describe themselves.
Have you recommended the product to anyone? What did you say?
ProbeAsk for the exact words. If they have not recommended it, ask why not.
Alternatives
5 minLearn what users would do without the product.
What would you use instead if the product were gone?
ProbeIf they say "nothing", ask how they would do the work. An easy alternative means weak fit.
What would make the change to that alternative hard?
ProbeAsk about data, habits, team members and cost.
What almost stopped you from using the product in the first weeks?
ProbeAsk what made them continue. This shows barriers for new users who are like them.
Improve and close
4 minFind what would make the product better for this user.
How could the product be better for you?
ProbeAsk for one change. For users who would be a little disappointed, ask what would make them disappointed a great deal.
What would make you use it more often?
ProbeDo not ask a follow-up. Thank them and end the interview.
Example finding
Solo consultants were more likely than agency staff to say they would be disappointed a great deal.
“It is my whole back office. Without it I would be back to email and three spreadsheets.”
Mistakes to avoid
- Do not ask people who used the product once. The test is for active users who know the product.
- Do not use the disappointment score alone. The reasons tell you which segment and which benefit to focus on.
- Do not try to please the users who would not be disappointed. Learn from the users who value the product most.
- Do not mix different segments in one score. Split the results by role or by company size.
Analyze the answers
Analysis templateResearch Insight Report Template: Findings, Insights, ActionsUse this template to write the report at the end of a qualitative study. Each element has a rule, so readers can tell facts from interpretation and see the strength of the evidence.Questions
It asks users how they would feel if they could no longer use the product. A large group of users who would be disappointed a great deal is a sign of fit.
A survey gives you the score. An interview gives the reason behind each answer, the alternative and the main benefit in the words of the user.
Plan 15 to 25 interviews for the reasons. If you want a reliable score, also send the fit question as a survey to a larger group.
Let the AI moderator ask these questions
The AI moderator interviews screened people by voice or text. Each claim in the study report links to its clip. The first 3 interviews are free.