Subscription Renewal Interview: Why Customers Renew or Cancel
Use this guide with customers who had a renewal date in the last 30 days. Include customers who renewed and who did not. It finds when the review started, how value was judged, and what decided the outcome.
- Length
- 20 min
- Questions
- 12
- People
- 10 to 14
- Sections
- 5
What this guide finds out
- If customers knew the renewal was coming, and how they found out.
- When customers start to review the value, and what evidence they use.
- How the price, a price change or a discount affected the decision.
- What almost changed the outcome for customers who renewed and for those who did not.
When to use it
- Annual renewals fall and the cancel form gives only short reasons.
- You plan a price change and must know how customers react at renewal.
- You want to design renewal reminders and value summaries.
Who to talk to
Customers whose renewal date was in the last 30 days, with a quota for renewed and for cancelled. Talk to 10 to 14 people. Each interview takes about 20 minutes.
The discussion guide
Each question has a probe note. The note tells the moderator, a person or an AI, what to do with the answer.
Warm-up
2 minLearn how the customer uses the subscription.
What do you use the subscription for, and how often?
ProbeAsk for the last time they used it. Record it as context.
Is this a monthly or a yearly plan, and who pays for it?
ProbeDo not ask a follow-up. Record the answer as context.
Before the renewal
5 minLearn if the customer expected the renewal and when the review started.
Did you know that your renewal was coming? How did you find out?
ProbeAsk if it was a reminder, a bank statement or their own calendar. If it was a surprise, ask how they felt.
When did you first think about whether to continue?
ProbeAsk what made them think about it at that moment. Ask how many days before the renewal date it was.
Did you think about this subscription together with others you pay for?
ProbeIf yes, ask which others and which ones they kept or cancelled.
Judging the value
6 minLearn how the customer judged the value of the past period.
How did you decide if the last period was worth the money?
ProbeAsk what evidence they used, such as usage, results or a feeling. Ask for one specific example.
What did you get from the subscription that you could not get elsewhere?
ProbeIf they say "nothing", ask what they use instead or plan to use.
How did the price at renewal compare with what you expected?
ProbeIf the price changed, ask how they learned about the change and how they reacted. Do not defend the price.
The decision
5 minLearn who decided and what almost changed the outcome.
Who else had a say in the decision?
ProbeAsk what that person cared about. For business plans, ask who approved the payment.
In the end, what made you renew or cancel?
ProbeAsk for the main reason, then ask what happened just before they decided.
What almost made you decide the other way?
ProbeFor renewers, record this as a risk. For cancellers, record it as a win-back lever.
Close
2 minGet one priority change.
What could we do before your next renewal to make the decision easier?
ProbeAsk them to name one change. Thank them and end the interview.
Example finding
Several annual customers learned about the renewal only from their bank statement, and some asked for a refund.
“I saw ninety-nine dollars on my card and had no idea what it was. I had not used it since March. I just wanted it back.”
Mistakes to avoid
- Do not interview only cancelled customers. Renewers who almost left show the risks that the next renewal holds.
- Do not ask about the renewal in general. Ask about this renewal date and the days before it.
- Do not offer a discount during the interview. It turns the interview into a sales call.
- Do not wait more than 30 days after the renewal date. The steps of the review fade quickly.
Analyze the answers
Analysis templatePricing Feedback Codebook: How to Analyze Pricing ResearchUse this codebook to code what customers say about your price. It separates complaints about the amount from complaints about how you charge, because each needs a different change.Questions
Interview within 30 days after the renewal date. Include customers who renewed and customers who cancelled, so you can compare their reviews of value.
Renewal does not mean the customer is happy. Some renew because they forgot, and some almost cancelled. They show the risks for the next renewal.
A churn interview talks only to people who cancelled. A renewal interview studies the decision point itself, for people on both sides of it.
Let the AI moderator ask these questions
The AI moderator interviews screened people by voice or text. Each claim in the study report links to its clip. The first 3 interviews are free.