Packaging Test Interview: Discussion Guide for Consumer Products
Use this guide to test a new or changed pack design with shoppers in the category. It starts with a shelf image, then looks at the front, the back and the claims. It ends with value and fit.
- Length
- 25 min
- Questions
- 13
- People
- 12 to 16
- Sections
- 5
What this guide finds out
- If shoppers notice the pack on a crowded shelf, and what makes them notice it.
- What shoppers think is inside, who it is for and how it is used.
- Which claims and symbols shoppers read, believe or ignore.
- What price shoppers expect from the pack, and how it compares with the brand they buy now.
When to use it
- You have 2 or 3 pack designs and must choose one before print.
- You change an existing pack and must check that loyal buyers still recognize it.
- You add a new claim, symbol or size and want to know if shoppers understand it.
Who to talk to
People who bought in this category in the last 30 days, with a quota for buyers of your brand. Talk to 12 to 16 people. Each interview takes about 25 minutes.
Screener for this guideRecent Purchaser Screener: Find People Who Just BoughtUse this screener to find people who bought a product in your category in the last 30 days. It confirms who chose and who paid, and checks the brand with a fake option.The discussion guide
Each question has a probe note. The note tells the moderator, a person or an AI, what to do with the answer.
Warm-up
3 minLearn how the participant shops for the category.
Tell me about the last time you bought [the category]. Where did you buy it, and which one did you choose?
ProbeAsk if they planned the brand before the shop or chose at the shelf. Record the brand name.
When you stand at the shelf for this, what do you look at first?
ProbeRecord each item they list. Do not suggest color, price or claims.
Shelf
5 minLearn if the pack stands out among competitors, before any focus on it.
Here is a picture of a shelf. Imagine you are in the store. Tell me what you notice.
ProbeShow a realistic shelf image with the test pack among 6 to 10 competitors. Do not point at the test pack. Record the order in which they name products.
Which product would you pick up first to look at more closely, and why?
ProbeIf they pick a competitor, ask what drew them to it. Do not ask about the test pack yet.
Front of pack
7 minLearn what the front of the pack communicates.
Now look at this pack. What do you think is inside?
ProbeShow the front only. Ask what on the pack told them that.
Who do you think would buy this pack?
ProbeAsk if they belong to that group. If not, ask who they would buy it for, if anyone.
What words or images do you notice first, and what do they tell you?
ProbeRecord the order. If they do not mention the main claim, do not point it out.
Is there anything on the front that you do not understand or do not believe?
ProbeAsk what would make the claim believable. Record unclear symbols by name.
Back of pack and price
7 minLearn which information shoppers look for and what value they expect.
If you held this pack in the store, what would you check on the back or the side?
ProbeShow the back. Ask them to find that information now and to say if it was easy to find.
What price would you expect this to cost in the store where you usually shop?
ProbeAsk what on the pack made them expect that price. Do not tell them the planned price.
How does this pack compare with the one you bought last time?
ProbeAsk for one thing that is better and one thing that is worse. Ask about size and amount, not only design.
Close
3 minGet a final view of the pack.
If you saw this pack next to your usual brand, what would you do?
ProbeAccept any answer. If they would stay with their usual brand, ask what the new pack would need to change that.
Is there anything else about the pack that you want to tell me?
ProbeThank them and end the interview.
Example finding
Several shoppers did not believe the "plastic-free" claim because the pack had a shiny surface that looked like plastic.
“It says plastic-free but it looks like plastic to me. That shiny bit, is that not plastic? I would not trust it.”
Mistakes to avoid
- Do not show the pack alone on a white background first. Shoppers see packs on a crowded shelf, so test that first.
- Do not tell participants which pack is new. They then comment on the design as critics, not as shoppers.
- Do not ask "Would you buy this?". Stated intent is often too high. Ask what they would do at the shelf next to their usual brand.
- Do not show 3D renders that look better than the printed pack. Use images that show the real colors and materials.
Analyze the answers
Analysis templateThematic Analysis Codebook: Starter Codes for InterviewsUse this codebook as the first pass on interview transcripts about a task or a workflow. The 10 codes describe what people do and why, so themes come from behavior, not from opinions.Questions
Show high-quality images of the shelf, the front and the back. Use photos of a printed sample if you have one. Ask shoppers to describe what they notice before you ask about details.
Show only one design per person if you can. If each person must see two or more, change the order for each person. The first design changes how people see the rest.
For qualitative feedback, start with 12 to 16 per design. To compare designs with numbers, use a survey with a larger sample after the interviews.
Yes. User Evaluation can show images at a chosen question. The AI moderator does not see the image or the screen, so ask participants to say what they notice.
Let the AI moderator ask these questions
The AI moderator interviews screened people by voice or text. Each claim in the study report links to its clip. The first 3 interviews are free.