Win-Loss Interview: B2B Discussion Guide and Questions
Use this guide to talk to buyers soon after a deal closes, won or lost. It finds how they built the shortlist, how they evaluated vendors and what decided the result.
- Length
- 30 min
- Questions
- 13
- People
- 10 to 20, about half wins and half losses
- Sections
- 5
What this guide finds out
- What started the search, and which requirements the buyer had at the start.
- How the buyer built the shortlist and evaluated each vendor.
- The main reason for the decision, and the reason that almost changed it.
- How price, contract terms and internal approval affected the result.
When to use it
- Your sales team gives "price" as the loss reason for most lost deals.
- Your win rate against one competitor drops.
- You plan a change to pricing, packaging or the sales process and want facts from buyers first.
Who to talk to
People who led or took part in a purchase decision in your category in the last 60 days. Talk to 10 to 20, about half wins and half losses people. Each interview takes about 30 minutes.
Screener for this guideB2B Decision-Maker Screener: Questions to Find Software BuyersUse this screener to find people who chose or approved a software purchase in the last 12 months. It checks the purchase role twice, so people who inflate their title fail.The discussion guide
Each question has a probe note. The note tells the moderator, a person or an AI, what to do with the answer.
Role in the decision
3 minLearn what part the person had in the purchase.
What is your role, and what was your part in this purchase?
ProbeFind out if they decided, evaluated, approved or will use the product. Adjust the depth of the next sections to their part.
Trigger and requirements
6 minFind what started the search and what the solution had to do.
What made your team start to look for a solution at that time?
ProbeAsk for the event, such as a renewal date, a new leader, a failure or a budget cycle.
What did the solution have to do? Which requirements were must-haves?
ProbeAsk who wrote the requirements. Ask if the list changed during the evaluation, and why.
The evaluation
9 minRebuild the steps from shortlist to final decision.
Which vendors did you consider, and how did you build the shortlist?
ProbeAsk where each vendor came from: a search, a peer, an analyst report or an existing contract.
Walk me through the evaluation, from the first call to the final decision.
ProbeAsk for each step, who joined it and how long it took. Note any step where a vendor dropped out.
How did each sales team work with you?
ProbeAsk for one good and one bad example. Do not ask for the names of sales people.
What did you see in a demo or a trial that changed your opinion?
ProbeAsk if the change was for or against a vendor. Ask what they expected to see instead.
The decision
9 minFind the deciding reason and the forces against it.
What was the main reason for your final choice?
ProbeAsk if one change by another vendor could have changed the result. If yes, ask which change.
What almost made you choose a different vendor?
ProbeAsk how close the decision was and what removed the doubt.
How did price and contract terms affect the decision?
ProbeSeparate the price level from the price structure and the terms. Ask if price decided the result or only broke a tie.
How did you get approval inside your company?
ProbeAsk who signed and which objections came from security, legal or finance. Ask which vendor made approval easier.
Advice and close
3 minGet direct feedback that the buyer did not give during the sale.
What advice would you give to the vendors that did not win?
ProbeAsk for one specific action. If the person is from a lost deal, this is advice for you.
Is there anything about the decision that we did not talk about?
ProbeIf they add a topic, ask one follow-up. Then thank them and end the interview.
Example finding
In lost enterprise deals, the decision often moved to the competitor during the security review, not during the demo.
“Your product was better in the demo. But the other vendor sent the security documents in one day, and we were on a deadline.”
Mistakes to avoid
- Do not let the account owner run the interview. Buyers do not tell the sales person the real reason they lost.
- Do not wait more than 60 days after the decision. The details of the evaluation fade quickly.
- Do not interview only losses. Wins show what to keep, and some wins were close to losses.
- Do not accept "price" as the full answer. Ask what the buyer compared the price with, and what value was missing.
Analyze the answers
Analysis templateWin-Loss Analysis Framework: Codes for Buyer InterviewsUse this framework to code interviews with B2B buyers after a deal closed, won or lost. Each decision factor gets a code and a direction, so wins and losses use the same scale.Questions
A win-loss interview is a conversation with a buyer after a purchase decision. It finds why the buyer chose your company or a competitor.
A person or a tool outside the sales team. Buyers are more open when they do not talk to the person who sold to them.
Start with 10 to 20, with about the same number of wins and losses. If you sell to different segments, plan at least 5 for each segment.
Yes. An AI moderator has no relationship with the buyer, so buyers can criticize the sales process without awkwardness. It also asks each buyer the same questions.
Let the AI moderator ask these questions
The AI moderator interviews screened people by voice or text. Each claim in the study report links to its clip. The first 3 interviews are free.